Enes
Moscow
WINNER OF THE RF MINSTROY MEDIA COMPETITION 2016
Go to mobile

LATEST NEWS

23:42 22-03-2017
Norway permits one of Russia’s richest man to develop Dvalin gas field
22:49 22-03-2017
Stroytransneftegaz built 50% of its Power of Siberia’s section ahead of schedule
22:08 22-03-2017
Ukrainian companies to be supplied with coal from South Africa
21:30 22-03-2017
British millionaires predict positive effect of Brexit on their capital
20:07 22-03-2017
Xiaomi opens second plant for smartphone production in India
19:14 22-03-2017
Russia's first cinema with a cylindrical screen to appear in Zaryadye Park
17:46 22-03-2017
Russia ready to cooperate with all partners over Nord Stream — Putin
17:21 22-03-2017
Russia and Egypt plan to prepare contracts for El-Dabaa NPP within two months
17:03 22-03-2017
UPS builds new terminal in Salt Lake City
16:48 22-03-2017
Businessmen strive to invest in Golf Resort in Gelendzhik
16:13 22-03-2017
Chairman of BASF to discuss with Vladimir Putin company’s operation in Russia
15:53 22-03-2017
Copy of Reichstag to be built in Russian Patriot Park by April 23
15:10 22-03-2017
Rosatom plans to produce 3D-printer of new generation by year-end
14:29 22-03-2017
Wintershall considers options for support of Nord Stream-2 project
13:48 22-03-2017
$87м medical cluster to be built in Moscow region within three years
12:55 22-03-2017
Japanese rehabilitation center to open in Russian city of Vladivostok this year
12:17 22-03-2017
Cottage of Russian billionaire robbed in French resort of Courchevel
11:29 22-03-2017
Mysterious ancient artifact found at Kerch Bridge construction site
10:36 22-03-2017
Greenhouses for year-round strawberry production set up in Khabarovsk region
09:41 22-03-2017
Russia to sign contracts with India on supplies of 48 Mi-17V-5 helicopters
19:40 21-03-2017
Moscow park may be named after Croatian city of Zagreb
19:20 21-03-2017
USA and Russia discuss project for Venus exploration
18:58 21-03-2017
Gazprom and Eni agree on gas supplies via Southern Corridor
18:27 21-03-2017
Dutch scientist develops concept for circular airport runways
17:55 21-03-2017
Russian region of Sverdlovsk and India to cooperate in water purification projects
17:28 21-03-2017
Belarusian President calls on to create new energy sources instead of gas and oil
17:14 21-03-2017
FSB conducts searches in St. Petersburg in new case over Presidential residence fraud
16:35 21-03-2017
Rosatom agrees on promotion of radiation technologies in Latin America
16:08 21-03-2017
$17,5m logistic hub to be built to facilitate trade between Russia and Kazakhstan
15:34 21-03-2017
Marriott sets to open 12 new hotels in Russia
All news

ARCHIVE NEWS

«    March 2017    »
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031 

Public hearings in construction: when will they become compulsory in Russia?

logo russianconstruction.com
Public hearings in construction: when will they become compulsory in Russia?

Passing by a construction site, people often ask themselves: and who has allowed it here? If a new draft bill is adopted, the question will naturally fall off.

Conflicts, and sometimes very acute, between constructors and inhabitants of nearby districts often arise in Russia. People are displeased with the construction starting near their house.  There were precedents when the protests ceased the construction. Both sides suffer in the result of the conflict. How can the interests of both parties be taken into consideration? A draft bill on public hearings allowing, from its authors’ point of view, to avoid such collisions, has been prepared in the RF Ministry of Construction, Housing and Utilities.  

 

We live here

A lot of cases have been found out in the process of the issue study, when a in big cities a high-rise building rises on the territory of a school, or a trade center on the place of a kindergarten.

Some time ago it was decided to build a hotel in the place of a parkland in Ulianovsk. All documents were executed according to law, and according to the existing papers, the public opinion was not negative.  But when constructors came to the site, people came out to a protest meeting.  

Such things occur because there are a lot of gaps in the Urban Development Code. And they become possible in the places where there are rich developers and the local authorities encourage them, Deputy of the State Duma of the 6th call, Olga Timofeeva, thinks.  To exclude the incidents the process of public hearings must be put in order.  

Two years ago, President of the Russian Federation, Vladimir Putin, signed the corresponding charge, and now the Ministry of Construction has prepared a draft bill to be introduced in State Duma. The document is aimed at making a backstop against public opinion manipulation. Residents’ opinions should be registered and really taken in consideration while taking urban development solutions.

 

Different in different regions

The situation with taking into account the opinion of the population is quite different in different regions and cities of Russia.

The existing mechanisms of informing people of the coming urban development initiatives do not allow to make a real picture of the public opinion, Igor Sapko, Head of the Perm municipal administration, thinks. So, conflicts between residents and developers arise.

A local legislative base for holding public hearings has been created in Perm. The existing land-use recommendations have been amended. One of the requirements is that during such events visual propaganda and the display of the  object to be constructed should be presented.

Besides, the registration form for the public hearings participants has been developed, which contain their proposals and expert opinion of the authorized committee.  Also informing the owners of nearby land plots and of apartments in multistoried blocks of flats is provided.

These measures allow to avoid the conflict situation at the initial stage, Perm Mayor is sure.  However all the measures are the initiative of local authorities and is not a compulsory element of the preparation for construction as they are not  prescribed by the Urban Development Code. But if corresponding amendments are introduced in law, the practice will be compulsory for all municipalities of the country.  

According to Igor Sapko, the present draft bill needs improvement. Especially it is necessary to take autonomous public bodies’ opinion into account, giving them powers to prepare and hold public hearings, as they know the real situation much better than officials.    

In Nizhny Novgorod public hearings on an important urban development project in a district with the population of 100,000 people, were attended only be…45 people. Vladimir Panov, Deputy of the City Duma, decided to clear out why people did not attend the meeting. It turned out that many of them wanted to express their opinion but they are not satisfied with either the ways and forms, or with the time of the event.  So, the Deputy thinks, the form and the ways of expressing public opinion should be altered. It is an acute problem and it is raised at every meeting with electorate.

 

Draft bill needs to be improved

According to Vladimir Panov, the draft bill solves all the problems. The terms of public hearings are enlarged. According to the new regulation, public hearings are to be held during a month (today they are organized on a day: who manages to come has the opportunity to say something).  

The form of the event is also changed: now they are called public hearings (that is a single event), and if the law is adopted they will become public discussions (it goes on a process, not a single event).

Another important thing to be included in the text of the draft bill – is providing the maximal availability of public materials. People should understand what it is all about.

Registration order for the participants of public discussions should be also established. As it is not now, the interested party may easily manipulate the public opinion. For example, invite engaged people to the event.  But if all participants are included in the lists, it would be more difficult to influence the final decision of the meeting, the Deputy is sure.

 The procedure of decision taking should be paid careful attention. Now it is voted. It seems to be the most widespread democratic way of clearing out the public opinion. But the thing is what number of citizens is needed for taking a decision. It hardly may be adopted if 45 people of 100,000 have voted, Vladimir Panov remarks. That’s why this issue requires further elaboration.

Bureaucratic sabotage

The fact that the presidential charge given two years ago has been fulfilled for so long is connected with the officials’ reluctance to share their powers. Sometimes they just formally organize a sort of hearings and then do what they intended to do.

There are both negative and positive examples of public hearings practice in the country, and a law is required having no gaps for the officials to execute it up to the point.

The new draft bill is aimed at reforming the institute of public hearings and enhancing their impact on the final resolution.

If the regulation on the citizens’ right to ban construction is introduced, then a referendum is necessary to be held, which is regulated by another law.

 

There are examples when people sopped trees cutting, constructions making a human shield. It is hardly optimal. The draft bill gives active citizens a tool to influence the situation. Olga Timofeeva does not exclude the situation when a draft bill will be altered significantly after a public discussion. Anyway, its task is to provide for maximal taking people’s opinion into account.

Adoption of the law is a step to a civilized dialogue.

 

Vladimir GURVICH 

Related publications

PARTNERS

UP