Enes
Moscow
WINNER OF THE RF MINSTROY MEDIA COMPETITION 2016
Go to mobile

LATEST NEWS

23:42 22-03-2017
Norway permits one of Russia’s richest man to develop Dvalin gas field
22:49 22-03-2017
Stroytransneftegaz built 50% of its Power of Siberia’s section ahead of schedule
22:08 22-03-2017
Ukrainian companies to be supplied with coal from South Africa
21:30 22-03-2017
British millionaires predict positive effect of Brexit on their capital
20:07 22-03-2017
Xiaomi opens second plant for smartphone production in India
19:14 22-03-2017
Russia's first cinema with a cylindrical screen to appear in Zaryadye Park
17:46 22-03-2017
Russia ready to cooperate with all partners over Nord Stream — Putin
17:21 22-03-2017
Russia and Egypt plan to prepare contracts for El-Dabaa NPP within two months
17:03 22-03-2017
UPS builds new terminal in Salt Lake City
16:48 22-03-2017
Businessmen strive to invest in Golf Resort in Gelendzhik
16:13 22-03-2017
Chairman of BASF to discuss with Vladimir Putin company’s operation in Russia
15:53 22-03-2017
Copy of Reichstag to be built in Russian Patriot Park by April 23
15:10 22-03-2017
Rosatom plans to produce 3D-printer of new generation by year-end
14:29 22-03-2017
Wintershall considers options for support of Nord Stream-2 project
13:48 22-03-2017
$87м medical cluster to be built in Moscow region within three years
12:55 22-03-2017
Japanese rehabilitation center to open in Russian city of Vladivostok this year
12:17 22-03-2017
Cottage of Russian billionaire robbed in French resort of Courchevel
11:29 22-03-2017
Mysterious ancient artifact found at Kerch Bridge construction site
10:36 22-03-2017
Greenhouses for year-round strawberry production set up in Khabarovsk region
09:41 22-03-2017
Russia to sign contracts with India on supplies of 48 Mi-17V-5 helicopters
19:40 21-03-2017
Moscow park may be named after Croatian city of Zagreb
19:20 21-03-2017
USA and Russia discuss project for Venus exploration
18:58 21-03-2017
Gazprom and Eni agree on gas supplies via Southern Corridor
18:27 21-03-2017
Dutch scientist develops concept for circular airport runways
17:55 21-03-2017
Russian region of Sverdlovsk and India to cooperate in water purification projects
17:28 21-03-2017
Belarusian President calls on to create new energy sources instead of gas and oil
17:14 21-03-2017
FSB conducts searches in St. Petersburg in new case over Presidential residence fraud
16:35 21-03-2017
Rosatom agrees on promotion of radiation technologies in Latin America
16:08 21-03-2017
$17,5m logistic hub to be built to facilitate trade between Russia and Kazakhstan
15:34 21-03-2017
Marriott sets to open 12 new hotels in Russia
All news

ARCHIVE NEWS

«    March 2017    »
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031 

How much money is there in off-the-books construction in Russia? 

logo russianconstruction.com
How much money is there in off-the-books construction in Russia? 

Why are all measures for legitimising the economy taken by the authorities doomed to failure in these current conditions?

Millions of our fellow citizens in construction and construction materials production do not pay taxes. Neighboring states get the income from accidental construction work in Russia. Is it possible to legalize the work of these people?  

 

Almost every other job is off the books

At the recent sitting of the council on strategic development and priority projects, the President of Russia, Vladimir Putin, charged officials with working out proposals on motivating the part of the population involved with the shadow economy to legalize their labour.

According to June’s poll, carried out by the Russian Presidential Academy of the National Economy and Public Administration, about 30m people work in the informal sector of the economy in Russia at present, which is 40.3% of the gainfully employed population of the country, totaling 76.5 m people. About 8.7 m people are totally excluded from the official economy whilst others have additional earnings which are either not registered officially or are received as hidden wages.

The scale of the “garage economy”, where non-registered employees (builders, counterfeit producers, taxi drivers, mechanics, traders, tailors, dentists and vets) work cash-in-hand is evaluated as a quarter of the GDP of Russia - about 18.4 trn roubles. (!)

How much money is there in off-the-books construction in Russia?  

50 shades of grey

The construction complex is traditionally among the industries in the “grey” economy, especially low-rise and wooden housing construction.

— The share of low-rise construction in the total volume of housing put into operation is 53—54%, Valery Kazeikin, Deputy Coordinator of the “Svoy Dom” State Duma Program on the development of low-rise housing construction told our journal. — Controlled development is about 14—15%. That is, 40% of all housing put in operation— about 20m square meters — is non-controlled development.

If we multiply these 20m by 35,000 roubles (the price according to the “Housing for the Russian Family” Presidential program) we get 700 bln roubles a year, from which the state might theoretically receive 300 bln roubles of taxes (more than $4.5 bln) – ‘might’, but does not. “Grey” operators do not pay taxes and their employees, citizens of  neighbouring states, do not spend 80% of their earnings in Russia but send them home.  

Thus, the total losses to the state on the “grey construction front” may be assessed as being as much as 3 trn roubles over the last 10 years (about $50 bln). The figures are impressive.

According to Valery Kazeikin, the majority of the houses built by such people are documented within the framework of “dacha amnesty”:

— A boss writes an application, specialists from the cadastral office come to measure the house and the land plot, and the former receives a permit for the house, so everything is legalized...

According to information from the National Agency for Low-Rise and Cottage Construction, most low-rise houses are put into operation in the North Caucasus, Siberia, Bashkortostan, Tatarstan and the Moscow region.

           And where do such agents work in Russia? The Director General of the Wood Housing Construction Association, Oleg Panitkov, has made a corresponding study of the regions (see table): the share of such agents is 25—50% of the total market participants. 

How much money is there in off-the-books construction in Russia?  

Share of grey brigades in the total number of wood housing construction market contractors (%) and citizenship of foreign builders

 

Region

Southern FD

Central FD

Volga FD

Ural

FD

Siberian FD

Far East FD

North-Western FD

Saint-Petersburg and LR

Moscow and MR

%

50%

40%

35%

30%

30%

30%

30%

25%

35%

Nationality

Ukraine

Belarus

Moldova

Central Asia

 

Belarus

Ukraine

Moldova

Central Asia

 

Belarus

Ukraine

Moldova

Central Asia

 

Belarus

Ukraine

Moldova

Central Asia

 

Central Asia

Belarus

Ukraine

China

China

Ukraine Belarus

 

Belarus

Ukraine

Moldova

Central Asia

 

Belarus

Ukraine

Moldova

Central Asia

 

Belarus

Ukraine

Moldova

Central Asia

 

Source: Wood housing construction Association

 

We are not slaves, but they are

— As opposed to other segments of the “garage economy”, the problem is that the majority of these people (55—60%, I think) are not Russian citizens, Oleg Panitkov stresses. — And consequently, in the total volume of the wood housing construction market, which we evaluate at as much as 1.5 bln roubles, the “grey” constructors’ earnings are a serious flow of capital, going abroad.

Legalizing the work of these people is a very complicated matter.

— It is necessary to make out documents for the right to work in Russia – firstly, a license. Then it is very desirable, but very difficult, to draw up a labour contract in writing with an employer, — the chairman of the migrant workers’ trade union, Renat Karimov, explained.  

As the “360” TV channel reported, there are more than 10m migrant workers in Russia, and only 1.5m of them have licenses for work.

As a result, many migrants actually enter into slavery. Recently the story of a citizen of the town of Serpukhov (Moscow region) was discussed all over the country: he found a note with a plea for help from a probable slave in the construction materials industry delivered by one of the timber works in Bratsk (Irkutsk region). He took the note to police. 

How much money is there in off-the-books construction in Russia?  

“Bad” does not mean “cheap”

Alongside with capital exports, there is another serious problem.

— Wood housing construction is mainly industrial now. Because of the “grey brigades” the capacity of our legal companies is only 30—40%, Oleg Panitkov complains. — So, to be profitable we have to produce houses at higher prices than we might. It means that we cannot implement the programs of available low-rise housing, and the state loses money in the form of taxes.

Besides, someone who chooses a “grey brigade” to build a house is taking great risks, as the work may be low quality, and threaten family members’ lives and health. As such brigades cannot carry out a professional project, they do not offer any guarantee…And, it is difficult to believe, but their work may be more expensive. Why?

They simply deceive customers by claiming lower prices, for one thing. Secondly, they buy construction materials in retail stores, while legal companies either buy them at wholesale prices, or produce them. Then they use low quality materials and tools, and under-qualified personnel.

How much money is there in off-the-books construction in Russia?  

Will SRO save us?

How can it be stopped?

— Citizens should show initiative themselves, Marina Konopleva, the Director General of “Komstrin-Perm” LLC, thinks. — They must check if the companies are members of an SRO, if they have the necessary licenses, if the SRO can be responsible for them in case their security is threatened. And if people cannot ask even these simple questions, such businesses will keep on blooming.

However, it is not so simple with SROs. Recently, the State Duma adopted

372-FL, developed by the Ministry of Construction, Housing and Utilities. According to this, companies with contracts of less than 3m roubles need not be members of an SRO, and their membership is voluntary. Contractors will now hire subcontractors themselves and will be responsible for the quality of their work.

As Victor Priadein, head of NOSTROY administration, explained, it allows one to decrease the financial and administrative load on businesses. However, part of the construction community forecasts the return of the 1990s, with even a larger number of “grey brigades” and other joys of the past.

— Instead of highly qualified construction organizations we’ll get pick-up work for contracts implementation, Novosibirsk constructors are sure. —The government has legalized the practices of unfair SROs instead of introducing strict controls. As far as good-faith SROs are concerned, they may become non-competitive in these new conditions.

So, people are first driven to dodgy operators and then measures are taken to drive them out. It is quite traditionally Russian.

How much money is there in off-the-books construction in Russia?  

Will insurance reform help?

— If such people exist, their participation in the economic life of Russia should be granted amnesty, the Vice-President of NAMIKS (National Agency for Low-Rise and Cottage Construction), Valery Kazeikin, reasons. — They should receive a license without any penalties for their activity, and be immune from taxation for, say, three years.

According to the expert, such an approach may be welcome: it is time to try to return this money to the economy, at least in part. Mr Kazeikin is sure that if President charged them to do so, the government and the deputies will take to the job.

But not everyone shares his optimism.

— There were lots of amnesties in different spheres, but, to tell the truth, I have never seen any significant effect from them, Oleg Panitkov states.

What is to be done? The Wood Housing Construction Association has proposed that the Ministries of Construction, Housing and Utilities and of Trade and Industry introduce a system of compulsory insurance for houses being constructed.

— I stress that it’s not about an SRO, but about the system of low-rise construction and wooden housing insurance, as it is done all over the world, Mr Panitkov explains. — If an insurance system is developed, insurance companies will not cover houses built by “grey brigades”, or will do so at a high rate.

So, the market regulator will appear automatically and will make customers seek reliable contractors, civilized and clear in their business.

— At least it is a practical measure, Oleg Panitkov remarked. — And I doubt that we can legalize millions of migrants …

And it is hard to argue.

How much money is there in off-the-books construction in Russia?  

In Russia and abroad

…Will the “garage economy” be overcome, resulting in trillions of additional roubles in the country’ purse? I am afraid we shall not live to see this glorious time.  

In such European countries as Germany, Finland and others, one would not be allowed to tile a bathroom or fix a power socket, and the buildings erected by professional constructors (not any Tom, Dick or Harry, as with us) meet all modern requirements and regulations in terms of ecology, security, energy efficiency, etc.

Such an approach is costly, of course. But standards of living in a country with a wealthy middle class provide demand for such an attitude towards buildings – meaning, the people who will live and work there.

And in Russia? While the government and the CB are destroying the middle class, making half the country poor, how can we speak about legalizing a modern approach to housing construction? That’s why we are building cheaper and with the help of half-literate migrant workers. How long will a house stand and will its residents’ health be threated? This issue is, alas, not so important for the majority of Russians.

We shall continue to discuss the problem of the shadow economy in the construction complex and our next article will be about “garage” production of construction materials.

 

Andrei CHERNAKOV

Related publications

PARTNERS

UP