Go to mobile


16:23 26-06-2017
Mongolia to join construction of Asian Super Grid
16:04 26-06-2017
$50-million stock breeding complex to be built in Russian Far East
15:40 26-06-2017
Fast neuron reactors help to make atom “green” – Rosatom’s head
15:07 26-06-2017
New bridge across Ob River in Siberia to be funded from federal budget
14:45 26-06-2017
Austrian Strabag to build musical road in Hungary
14:09 26-06-2017
Company with Turkish capital to build first phase of Saratov airport
12:55 26-06-2017
Ismailov’s mall in Las Vegas seized for debts to Bank of Moscow
12:19 26-06-2017
Jewish community gets historic synagogue in Simferopol
11:49 26-06-2017
Sales of new buildings in USA grew by 3%
11:22 26-06-2017
Georgia completes construction of its largest nuclear power plant
10:39 26-06-2017
Using Nord Stream 2, Russia takes revenge on Ukraine - Poroshenko
09:50 26-06-2017
Russian billionaire’s company buys British Holland & Barrett
16:56 23-06-2017
Cabinet of Ministers allotted land plot for construction runway-3 in Sheremetievo
16:31 23-06-2017
KamAZ to invest €50m in production in Senegal
14:46 23-06-2017
Lukoil won a tender on supply of 2,700 tons of oil to Severstal enterprises
14:17 23-06-2017
President Putin to control pipeline mating at the Turkish Stream construction
13:37 23-06-2017
Reconstruction of Moscow conservatoire to be completed
13:26 23-06-2017
Thrill rides to be built in Moscow Luzhniki
12:54 23-06-2017
Unique green roofing to be built in Moscow during renovation
12:32 23-06-2017
The Chinese participating in Moscow Metro construction
11:16 23-06-2017
Grand fraud discovered at a business centre construction site in Krasnoyarsk
18:02 22-06-2017
Rostec to restore enterprise producing acoustic equipment
17:50 22-06-2017
Seven plants to open in Dubna special economic zone
17:35 22-06-2017
Putin heads for Anapa to control Turkish Stream pipeline link-up
17:12 22-06-2017
Heineken sells its brew-house in Belarus
16:53 22-06-2017
Tesla signs preliminary agreement on plant building in China
16:35 22-06-2017
Industrial warehouse in northern Moscow put on auction for $751,000
16:02 22-06-2017
China suggests project for Changchun – Vladivostok high-speed railway
15:33 22-06-2017
Europe’s gas demand exceeds Nord Stream 2 capacity, Wintershall says
14:56 22-06-2017
Poland to demolish 500 monuments to Soviet soldiers
All news


«    June 2017    »

Construction expertise: Minister Menn stands for integral system, but qualified experts are lacking

logo russianconstruction.com
Construction expertise: Minister Menn stands for integral system, but qualified experts are lacking

How to improve the condition of the state expertise for construction objects

Annually, state and non-state expertise assess more than 55,000 objects of capital construction. In fact, every forth project receives unfavourable comments, and lately the number of negative reports has reached 45%.  Meanwhile, specialists dealing with construction expertise think their labour is underestimated. The topic was under discussion at the II All-Russia conference of state expertise organizations.

Few for many

Presently, expertise is of special importance. In their rush for income, constructors are sometimes ready to compromise the quality of their work. Often, experts are the only barrier against the violation of existing norms and regulations in project design and construction. 

There is no use enumerating the objects where the laid-down cost was surpassed multifold. In turn, a lot of cases remain unknown. 

In 2015, due to expertise, 500 bln roubles were saved (about $7.794m), and for 9 months of 2016 180 bln roubles (more than $2.8m). There were more than 3,000 experts’ evaluations for the objects with a laid-down cost of 1trn roubles ($15.6 bln), and the RF Minister of Construction, Housing and Utilities, Mikhail Menn, shared the statistics.

Minister Menn voiced the figures deliberately, as he knows very well how the level of project documentation has lowered in the post-Soviet period. According to Valery Leonov, Chair of Moscow Expertise Committee (Moskomexpertiza), every fourth project receives a negative evaluation. However, if the experts were stricter, the figure would be higher.

The control over the situation may be lost if the level of expert evaluations is not raised. More importantly, everybody is complaining about the quality of new constructions, even in the elite class of housing. According to Mikhail Menn, the way out of the situation is in the creation of an integral efficient expert system combining both state and private sectors. 

Construction expertise: Minister Menn stands for integral system, but qualified experts are lacking

Additionally, during the crisis the importance of expertise has grown as project designers and builders strive to save on every stage of the construction process. 

According to Igor Manylov, Head of “Glavexpertiza Rossii” (Chief Expertise of Russia) FAI, the task of the state is to develop and enhance the expertise institute.

Today, the number of Russian experts is rather modest: there are 7 696 certified professionals annually evaluating 55,000 objects of capital construction for a very moderate payment. The amount does not even recompense the expenses on expert evaluations. For this work specialists receive only 0.58% of the project’s cost.

For example, the audit check of an object costing 4 bln roubles ($62,4 m) will cost only 100,000—150,000 roubles ($1,600 – $2,350). By comparison, a foreign company was paid 50m roubles ($779,389) for the audit check of a 9 km long section of the CRR. 

Furthermore, only 12 specialists deal with analysing the whole document collection and at least 25 are actually needed.

The appeals to save on expertise are very dangerous. On the contrary, it needs additional investment, otherwise it is impossible to raise its quality, Igor Manylov resumed.


The situation really needs to be corrected. Putting it into other words the famous saying by Winston Churchill, “Never will so much be owed by so many to so few” encapsulates everything. 


Diversion complexity 

Revolutionary changes in the state expertise experience will take place from January 1st, 2017, when they will be diverted to a full-scale non-legible form. The process has already lasted for several years. Thus, since 2014, the necessity to provide claimers with the electronic services in the sphere of state expertise has been formalized in legislation.


According to Vadim Andropov, First Deputy Head of “Glavexpertiza Rossii” FAI,  in 2014 all project designers, builders and expert organizations were told to take measures for the transition to new technologies. Its process is still going on, but its pace leaves much to be desired.


According to the expert, half of the regions had done nothing until April 1st, 2016. At present, 32 federal regions have a high level of readiness, and 3% have done nothing. The highest readiness is marked in the Ural FD, and the lowest in the Far Eastern FD. The average integral index of readiness by October 1st showed only 53.7%. 


As Vadim Andropov admits, the real condition may be worse, as not all of the regions provide reliable data.


At the same time, the number of documents in non-legible form is growing. For the last three months, 420 e-form documents have been registered. But the flow of documents is not even. The system will be more efficient when the integral information space, including builders, project designers and experts, is created. And it is not likely to happen by the beginning of the new year.


However, the transition as it is does mean a new qualitative level in the sphere of project design and expertise.


Vladimir GURVICH 

Related publications